Feeding a Crowd
By Jennifer Slaugh, senior staff writer

 

Family reunions. Ward parties. Missionary departures and returns. Baby blessings. Weddings. Fly a Kite Day.

It seems we just can’t find enough reasons to gather lots of our friends and family together and eat. Unfortunately, without some advanced planning your gathering could end up more chaotic than enjoyable.

Feeding a crowd is different than feeding your family, and we have put together some recipes, tips, and considerations that will aid you in making your next gathering a success.

Catered vs. Homemade
I come from a family of bakers, so it is no surprise that food is a major part of every family gathering. But even we know our limits.

Story #1: When Good Food Goes Bad
One Thanksgiving my extended family gathered in St. George to celebrate together. We reserved the local ward building—the only place large enough for all 94 of us—and set up shop. Join me for a scene from the kitchen:

Aunt #1: Who was in charge of starting the turkey to thaw? It should have been started hours ago.

Aunt #2: Who brought these rolls? Are they store bought?

Aunt #3: I don’t know why anyone thought it would be a good idea to put walnuts on top of this pumpkin pie. Doesn’t everyone know that my Bobby is allergic to nuts? One bite and…

Aunt #1: If we can’t figure out a way to thaw this turkey everything is going to be ruined!

Aunt #4: We have hours and hours until dinner. I’m sure it will all work out.

Aunt #3: You’re stuffing it all wrong! Let me show you a better way. I’ve been put in charge of all the food events in my ward and I have just learned the best ways to do things.

Aunt #5: Has anyone seen Mother? We need her for some pictures. We also need all of you to come out for some pictures.

Aunt #2: Maybe if more people were helping get things ready we would have time to come out for pictures. My oh my.

Aunt #1: Look, if you don’t like the way I’m doing things, then just say so. I can leave it for you to do.

Aunt #4: This is fun isn’t it? All being in the kitchen together? It’s nice.

Even with the best of intentions, too many sisters in the kitchen together can spoil the family reunion broth.

Story #2: I Didn’t Make It, But I Like It
Last summer my same extended family gather again, but this time in Nauvoo. I was in charge of planning this reunion, and remembering the fun of baking together from St. George, I decided that all meals eaten all together were going to be catered. Join me for a scene from the park:

Aunt #1: Look, everything is set up and ready to eat. Where are my kids?

Aunt #2: Everything is store bought and it’s wonderful.

Aunt #3: This is a beautiful park.

Aunt #4: This is fun isn’t it? All being at the park and visiting together? It’s nice.

Aunt #5: Smile for the camera!

Sometimes it is better to make the food and sometimes it is better to let someone else make it for you. If you are traveling a long distance, feeding more than 50 people, have no kitchen area in your hotel, or a celebrating the wedding of one of your own children, please seriously consider saying “no” to any and all food assignments.

Full Meals vs. Snacks and Dessert
The amount of food you will need will depend upon the age, time of day and activities of the people you will be serving. You might have individual families eat dinner on their own, but gather the entire family for ice cream sundaes. A word of caution: don’t serve light snacks over a regular meal time. No one, especially children, can eat just a snack when they are ready for a full meal.

Time Apart vs. Time Together
Because very few vacation locations include a kitchen large enough for five cooks, let alone the whole family, it is likely that during meal prep times the extended family will be separated. If you plan meals that require very little prep time and no baking time this might not be a problem at all, but if your meal assignment involves chopping, mixing, and baking, you can plan that you’ll be spending at least the entire hour before meals just getting ready for them. If you have traveled a long distance and will only be with your family for a short period of time, the time required to prepare meals separately might not be worth the money saved on making your own meals. On the other hand, if there is a kitchen facility available that will accommodate several cooks, and you plan easy-to-prepare meals, taking turns on kitchen duty can be a fun way to visit with small groups of your family.

Renting vs. Packing it All
While you may be tempted to just pack everything you will need and transport it to the reunion location, consider renting large or bulky items from a party rental store in your destination city. You can rent things like tables, chairs, tablecloths, serving platters, and big bowls. This will be especially helpful if you will already have a car full of family and luggage. You should also consider purchasing necessary food items once you have arrived at the reunion location. If you do this you won’t have to worry about food safety while you travel, but you will also have to do all the preparation work once the food is purchased—a challenge if your hotel does not have a kitchen.

Other logistical considerations—especially for out-of-town gatherings
Seating: be sure to plan for tables and chairs for all meals. It might seem like a good idea to have every throw down a blanket for a good old-fashioned picnic, but chances are there will be members of the family, especially older members, who would prefer a chair and table.

Prep space: Some questions to ask your self: Does this meal require a lot of chopping? Do I need to plate individual portions before serving? Do I usually have help when preparing this and need space for someone else to work alongside me? Be sure that you will have enough counter space to prepare your meals.

Baking space: Some hotel ovens are smaller than the standard ovens in most homes. Check on the size with the hotel staff while you are planning your meals to be sure that you usually baking dishes will fit in the oven. Also, if you will need to bake more than one thing at a time be sure to check that the oven has multiple racks.

Utensils: Many hotels at popular Latter-day Saints gathering locations offer fully stocked kitchens in each room. If this is an option for you, check with the hotel staff to be sure that the supplies provided are the ones you will need. If your meals plans involved several homemade dishes, be sure to check on oven space, fridge space, counter space, and utensils, including pots and pans. It would also be wise to make sure that you have serving dishes, cutting knives, dish towels and dish soap, and the necessary spices. If the hotel does not provide a stocked kitchen, go through your recipes a few time to anticipate what utensils and space you will need. Make sure that your menu doesn’t require things that you will not have access to—lots of freezer space, for example.

Food safety and clean-up: For the safety of everyone eating, food should not be left out of the oven or refridgerater for long periods of time. If your family activities call for a picnic lunch in the mountains and then a hike, be sure to put away all food items and discard anything that needs immediate refridgeration so that you won’t be tempted to put yourself or others at risk by snacking on it when you return.

Food Options for a Large Family Gathering
Pot-luck
• For short events (such as an afternoon or evening) where most or all of those attending live nearby, the easiest way to feed a crowd is to plan a potluck meal.

• Be sure to specify what is expected from each family. My Aunt Brenda tells stories of potluck gatherings where extended family groups of 27 arrived together with only one small bowl of salad to share. If you expect everyone to bring enough food to feed their own family, make sure you make that expectation clear.

• Have extra serving utensils and storage containers on hand for those who forget to bring them.

Assigned baking times
• If your family is having a longer reunion and decides to prepare all the meals, be sure to refuse to do it alone. Form a committee of several family members who are comfortable in the kitchen to help plan menus, purchase and store food, assign families to specific meals, and follow up to make sure the food is getting made. You can also assign out the different meals and let those families be responsible for purchasing the food. Sometimes it is easier to have one person buy all the food because then the family knows who to pay for their meals. Remember that the more assignments you pass out, the more you have to be willing to accept what other people produce. Also be sure to make clean-up assignments and utensil (plates, cups, cutlery, etc) assignments.

• It can be difficult to know in advance how much to charge your family for the food purchased. If you know the cost of the food in advance, I recommend sharing that information early so you can leave the reunion with all the money paid back. Some families have a small auction where each family donates something to be auctioned, family members bid on the different items, and the money collected goes into the next reunion fund.

Catered meals
• If you decide to have a catering take care of your reunion/event meals, keep in mind that you don’t have to use them for everything. Non-perishable food items, especially for snacks, are easy to do on your own.

• Ask for references from other families who have held an event in the area you are traveling to. Be sure to request at least three references from the caterer and call them.

• Some grocery stores or sandwich shops and provide you with large-scale meals. For our Nauvoo reunion we used a local grocery store for the main meal items, which made it convenient to purchase the smaller items when we were picking up the main dish. For example, we had one dinner of BBQ beef sandwiches. From the same grocer who provided the prepared beef we also purchased our sandwich rolls, chips, fruit and veggies trays, and dessert cookies.

No group meals
• It is possible to gather for several days with your family and not have a combined meal.

Everyone contributes a certain part of the dinner
• Similar to the potluck idea, but for this method you would let everyone know the main dinner item, for example tacos, and then assign each family a part of that dinner. One family can bring chopped tomatoes and lettuce, another the taco shells, another the cooked and seasoned beef, etc. This divides up the cost and preparation time but stills allows you to eat all together.

Don’t have every meal together
• Breakfasts and lunches can be “fend for yourself” and the large family can gather only in the evenings for a shared meal.

 

Food is bound to play a large role in your overall planning of any family gathering or large event, but it doesn’t need to be completely overwhelming. Share the load and take help where you can get it. Be certain that you don’t spend the entire reunion in the kitchen—having a great time visiting, playing games, reminiscing, and exchanging pictures and family stories contribute to the enjoyment of these family get-togethers.

Helpful websites:

Have a favorite family recipe you want to serve 100 people. Have someone else do the math for you! Here are two different websites to help you make your recipe go from serving 10 to serving 100 in a flash!

Recipe Conversion: you can enter in the amounts and ingredients for any recipe and it will convert it to a larger or smaller amount.

Any recipe posted at allrecipes.com can be scaled to feed a larger or smaller crowd.

Additional Resource:

Gloria Rytting, “Cooking for a Crowd: How to Be an Instant Expert,”
Ensign, June 1979, 64

Banana Chocolate
Chip Muffins

Makes 70+ muffins

8 cups flour
1 T. + 2 t. baking powder
1 1/2 t. salt
1 lb. butter
2 cups brown sugar
8 cups bananas, mashed (about 16 bananas)
8 eggs
1-1/3 cups milk
1T. + 1t. vanilla
3 cups chocolate chips (I use semi-sweet mini chips)

Combine dry ingredients except sugar in a LARGE bowl or tub and set aside. Cream butter and sugar, beat in eggs, stir in milk, vanilla and mashed bananas. Add wet ingredients to dry ingredients using a large spoon and big strokes to just combine the mixtures. Do not over mix. Carefully spoon into well greased muffin tins. Bake at 400°F until done (15 min. approx.)

 

Potato Chowder

Serves 50

1-1/2 lb. margarine
1 cup flour
8 lb. potatoes, peeled and sliced, weigh after peeling
2 cups water
1 qt. sliced fresh onions
1 gal. plus 3 qt. milk
1 qt. celery, finely chopped
1 qt. shredded carrots
1/4 cup chopped fresh parsley

Sauté onions in margarine until clear but not brown. Add flour and blend. Add milk and let come to a boil, stir in parsley. Steam potato, celery and carrots until tender. Add to cream sauce. Salt to taste.

Variation: 1 lb. cooked diced bacon can be added to the soup.

 

Chicken Tetrazzini

Serves 20

1 lb spaghetti, broken into pieces
3 (10.75 oz) cans condensed cream of mushroom/chicken/ celery soup
12 oz. shredded Cheddar cheese
6 cups shredded boiled chicken breast meat
1 lb sauteed mushrooms with a small onion & garlic
1 (4 oz) jar sliced pimento peppers, drained
2 cups chicken broth
French Fried Onions
Grated fresh parmesan

Preheat oven to 350°F. Bring a large pot of salted water to a boil. Add uncooked spaghetti (broken into thirds) to the pot and cook for 8 to 10 minutes or until al dente. Drain and set aside.

In a large saucepan, heat soup over low heat. Add shredded cheese (reserve some for topping) and stir together. Then add the cooked shredded chicken, mushrooms, pimento peppers and cooked spaghetti and stir all together. Add enough of the reserved broth to make it 'sloppy' and mix all together.

Divide mixture between two a 9x13 inch baking dishes. Sprinkle each with reserved shredded cheese, top with french fried onions, grated fresh parmesan and bake in the preheated oven for 25 to 35 minutes or until bubbly.

From allrecipes.com.

 

Potato Salad

Serves 50

5 lbs potatoes, cooked, cooled, cut into small pieces
1 small onion, finely diced
3 tsp salt
1 tsp pepper
2 cups Italian dressing
2 cups mayonnaise
4 Tbsp mustard
3 Tbsp sweet relish
1 cup finely chopped celery
8 hard boiled eggs, diced

This is a “oh, I just add some until it looks right” recipes from my mom. I’ve tried to nail down the specific measurements, but some things are just “to taste.”

Once potatoes are cooked, cooled and cut, combine with Italian dressing, salt, pepper, and onion. Let sit at least three hours or overnight. Combine mayonnaise (enough to coat your potatoes but not drown them), mustard (enough to give the salad and light yellow color), and sweet relish. Fold, along with celery and eggs, into potatoes. Top with sliced, hard boiled eggs, and sprinkle with paprika.

From Cheryl Slaugh

 

BBQ Pulled Pork Sandwiches

Serves ~20

6-7lb. pork shoulder roast
salt and pepper
2 tablespoons Liquid Smoke
2 tablespoons BBQ sauce

Place roast in a slow-cooker. Sprinkle with salt and pepper, liquid smoke and BBQ sauce. Cook on low for 10 hours. Pour off any liquid and shred pork. Serve on hamburger buns with more of your favorite BBQ sauce. Freezes and reheats well.

From Ginny Clark.

 

Make Ahead Mashed Potatoes

Makes ~14 cups

10 lbs. potatoes
2 eggs
1 tsp. garlic powder or garlic salt
2 tsp. salt
6 Tbsp. butter or margarine,melted
8 oz. cream cheese

Peel and quarter potatoes. Place in saucepan and cover completely with water. Bring to a boil, then gently cook until tender. Drain well. In large bowl, combine potatoes, cream cheese, eggs, garlic powder/salt, melted butter or margarine and salt. Mash well by hand or with electric mixer. Place in 1 gallon Ziploc freezer storage bag (s) and refrigerate or freeze for future use.

From Ginny Clark.

 

Chicken Salad for 100

12 lb. boned turkey or chicken
4 bunches celery, chopped
1 bunch green onion, chopped
3 large (20 oz.) cans pineapple tidbits, drained
2 lb. pkg forzen peas
1lb. buttered toasted almonds, slivered or sliced
3 qt. homemade dressing (see below)
2 qt. mayonnaise

Dressing:
1/2 cup sugar
3 tablespoons flour
1 tablespoon dry mustard
1 teaspoon salt
3 eggs, well beaten
1 cup milk
1 cup vinegar

This makes 3 cups of dressing, you will need to make it 4 times for this recipe. Cook the dressing slowly until thick. Can add pineapple juice to dressing.

From Shannon Wilson.

COPYRIGHT © 2000-2008. MORMONCHIC.COM, ALL RIGHTS RESERVED.
CONTACT US  |  ABOUT US  |  PRIVACY POLICY  |  TERMS OF USAGE  | DISCLAIMER  |  OFFICIAL LDS WEBSITE